Free professional paper writing assistance from expert writers
The Dream Act is a bill proposed to the United States Senate in August 2001. The purpose of the bill is to provide a legal basis for a mechanism that will enable undocumented immigrants who are within a specified age range to attain permanent residency of the U.S. by first fulfilling certain conditions. Dream Act stands for Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors. Even though this bill has been reintroduced several times after its initial introduction, it is yet to pass.
Proposed Mechanism and Requirements
The bill is proposed for a two stage acquisition of permanent residency. The first a temporary residency permit upon meeting specified conditions and the permanent residency is gained after having fulfilled a set of further requirements. In order to acquire temporary residency under the proposed terms of the Document, one would have to fulfil the following conditions: provide documentary evidence that they entered into the country aged below sixteen years of age and have been resident in the country for a minimum of five years, must have graduated from a high school in the U.S. or be in possession of a General Education Development certificate; show good moral behaviour and be certified free of a criminal history. A would-be beneficiary having attained temporary residency can qualify for permanent residency after six years if the following conditions are met: must have graduated from a higher institution or serve in the United States military for a minimum of two years and achieve an honourable discharge; be free of any criminal record; and be of good moral conduct.
Opposition and Criticism of the Act
Critics as well as opponents of the proposed bill have raised doubts about its potential benefits and expressed reservations as to its potential for criminal abuse and possible compromise of the American immigration system. Much of the criticisms have centred on its perception as the equivalent of an ‘amnesty’ program and tacit approval of illegal immigration into the United States, thus creating room for criminal elements to be legally shielded from deportation.
Arguments of those Who Support the Bill
Those who favour the bill offer a number of arguments, chiefly highlighting what they perceive as the potential benefits of the bill. Proponents of the bill are of the opinion that it will - in the near term or on the long run - be beneficial for the country’s education, economy and the military because it targets only the brightest of young people who have already been living in the U.S. They describe the act as a logical one considering the fact that many of its proposed beneficiaries have been living in the U.S without having chosen to do so because they were brought in by their parents.
Thesis Statement Broad topic Immigration More specific topic Dream Act Research question Should the Dream Act legislation pass and become law Purpose for writing paper To show that the Dream Act legislation should pass and become law Opinion about topic The Dream Act should pass and become law Reasons for 1. The Dream Act will dramatically increase the pool of highly qualified recruits for the U. S. Armed Forces. 2.
The Dream Act will provide a path to legalization for educated, dedicated individuals who will pay their taxes, purchase homes, and overall contribute to the U. S. economy. 3. The Dream Act is a great return on the money we have already invested and will prepare the country for the global economy. 4. The Dream Act will reduce high school dropout rates and enable more students to attend college. 5. The Dream Act is supported by 70percent of the likely voters and by leaders in education, the military, businesses and religious orders.
Reasons against 1. The Dream Act will be funded on the backs of hard working, law-abiding Americans. 2. Conservatives estimates suggest that at least 1. 3 million illegal aliens will be eligible for the Dream Act amnesty. 3. The Dream Act is not limited to children; applicants can be up to the age 29. 4. Certain criminal aliens will be eligible for amnesty under the Dream Act. 5. Passing the Dream Act would encourage more illegal immigration. Thesis statement
The Dream Act legislation should pass and become law because the outcome of doing so will benefit the U. S. , the Dream Act will increase recruits for the U. S. Armed Forces, it will also provide a path of legalization to educated individuals that will pay taxes and overall contribute to the U. S. economy, it will also help reduce high school dropout rates and enable more students to attend college, it is supported by 70 percent of likely voters that include leaders in education, military, businesses and religious orders.